We have been through what feels like every single product on the market. Last summer we had luck with Bullfrog, and this year it completely peels her skin. For a couple of weeks A&D baby (from Walmart) was working, then it started peeling her, too. Now we are using Vanicream Sport, and it has worked for over a month. It's pricey, but worth it.
4 year old daughter with CIE